Sydney’s pizza scene has evolved over the years to become a pretty serious business. Of course, there are thousands of pizzerias to choose from in the greater Sydney area, but not all slices are created equal. At least, not in our opinion.
Of course, you can argue the merits of a late-night Dominoes and cheesy garlic bread, or whether deep dish or crispy crust rules supreme. And for the lactose-avoidant, pizza can be a touchy subject altogether. But luckily, at RUSSH, we've got all bases – and suburbs – covered.
Whether you're after a fragrant wood-fired classic, or hunting for an authentic Margherita, here’s where to go for the best pizza in Sydney.
1. Pizza Oltra (Haymarket)
View this post on Instagram
Tucked into the back of Central Station, Pizza Oltra is a gem for those greasy, deep-dish style square pizzas that have all the trimmings. The cozy, laid-back atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for catching up with friends over a casual, delicious meal, and their menu champions creativity and seasonal ingredients.
2. Bella Brutta (Newtown)
View this post on Instagram
A favourite of our Fashion Director Hannah Cooper (who tells us their chilli zucchini pizza is "unbelievable"), Bella Brutta has earned a reputation for its innovative approach to pizza, featuring wood-fired creations with bold, unique toppings like fermented chilli and clams. Their space is minimalist, yet vibrant, and their menu focusses focus on flavour, texture, and top-notch ingredients.
3. Donny's Pizza (Abbotsford)
View this post on Instagram
Our Studio Manager Liv's pick is Donny's, of which she says it's "just really simple, good pizza". Located in Abbotsford, it's a local favourite, serving up wood-fired pizzas with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The cozy, laid-back atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a casual night out or a quick bite with friends. Their menu features creative topping combinations, giving a unique twist to classic pizza flavours.
4. Gigi's Pizza (Newtown)
View this post on Instagram
It's not unusual for the vegan option to feel a little lackluster, but you know it's a good sign when a vegan pizzeria like Gigi's is being flocked to by omnivores as well. With a gorgeous selection of well-though-out pizzas and sides, this is a great, casual spot for romancing your dairy-free and vegetarian friends (with plenty of gluten-free options too). We'd highly recommend the "Cavolo" with cauliflower puree, artichokes, pine nuts, capers, currants, garlic and parsley.
5. Dimitri's Pizzeria (Darlinghurst)
View this post on Instagram
A personal favourite of mine is Dimitri's, which sits across three storeys on Oxford street near Taylor's Square. On a gorgeous summer evening, opt for the rooftop for a crisp setting under the stars. The Bee Sting (sopressa and hot honey) is a must. The focaccia is also killer if you're looking to double-up on carbs for the night too. I'd suggest booking ahead for this one (or opting for takeaway if you're in a pinch).
6. Pizza Riccardo (Narrabeen)
View this post on Instagram
Our Digital Strategy Director & Associate Publisher Mia's pick in the Northern Beaches is Pizza Riccardo in Narrabeen, nestled just moments from the beach. The joint offers the perfect post-surf dining spot with its authentic wood-fired pizzas, and a menu that features everything from the classic Margherita, with San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella, to gourmet creations like the Prosciutto e Rucola, with thin prosciutto, peppery rocket, and Parmesan.
7. Pocket Pizza (Manly)
View this post on Instagram
Another favourite of RUSSH team members north of the bridge is Pocket Pizza in Manly, a vibrant, laid-back spot tucked just off the main strip. Pocket Pizza is a cozy, retro-inspired atmosphere with neon signs and outdoor seating that serves up a range of creative pizzas like the spicy ‘Chilli Prawn’ with garlic prawns, chilli, and rocket, and the indulgent ‘Pepperoni Deluxe’ loaded with mozzarella and a spicy honey drizzle.
8. I Gladiatori Osteria Romana (Freshwater)
View this post on Instagram
I Gladiatori Osteria Romana brings the flavours of Rome to life with its traditional Italian dishes and rustic ambiance. Located in a cozy, intimate space, the restaurant offers a warm, welcoming vibe, perfect for savouring plates like Cacio e Pepe or Roman-style pizza topped with rich, fresh ingredients. The menu highlights authentic Roman recipes, from the tender Saltimbocca alla Romana to hearty pasta dishes, all served in an atmosphere that transports you to the heart of Italy.
9. Nude Pizza (Malabar)
View this post on Instagram
Our assistant-to-the-editor and resident Paul Mescal enthusiast Samantha Corry tells me her favourite is "Nude Pizza in Malabar (near me) chef Colin Fassnidge agrees with me too!" Nude is a local gem, offering fresh, handmade pizzas in a relaxed, beachside setting. The venue’s laid-back vibe pairs perfectly with menu favourites like the 'Truffle Shuffle,' a decadent mix of truffle oil, mushrooms, and mozzarella, or the 'Prawnstar,' featuring garlic prawns, cherry tomatoes, and rocket.
10. Bsp'eria (Penhurst)
View this post on Instagram
Content director Elyssa Kostopulos tells me Bsp'eria in Penshurst is a personal favourite, offering a warm, inviting space where diners can enjoy wood-fired pizzas made with care and high-quality ingredients. Their 'Diavola' pizza delivers a kick with spicy salami, fiery fresh chilli, and rich mozzarella, while the 'Capricciosa' balances flavours with thinly sliced ham, earthy mushrooms, tender artichokes, and briny olives. Located in the heart of the neighbourhood, Bsp'eria is a popular spot for locals looking for authentic Italian flavours, whether for a casual midweek meal or a lively gathering with friends and family on the weekend.
11. Vacanza Pizzeria (Bronte and Surry Hills)
View this post on Instagram
For digital editor Kirsty Thatcher, Vacanza Pizzeria is the go-to. With locations in Surry Hills and Bronte, it's beloved for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas made in a traditional wood-fired oven. The 'San Daniele' is a crowd favourite, featuring delicate slices of prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, and a touch of rocket, while the 'Bufalina' highlights creamy buffalo mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, and fragrant basil.
12. Westwood Pizza (Newtown)
View this post on Instagram
Westwood Pizza in Newtown has quickly gained a reputation for its inventive, small-batch wood-fired pizzas, made with a focus on quality and simplicity. Their menu includes standout options like the 'Smoked Potato and Garlic' pizza, featuring a unique blend of smoked potatoes, roasted garlic, and rosemary, as well as the ‘Pepperoni’ with house-made pepperoni, chilli, and honey for a sweet and spicy kick.
13. The Dolphin Hotel (Surry Hills)
View this post on Instagram
Perhaps an unexpected favourite, Crown street's The Dolphin actually serves up a killer lineup of pizzas day and night. They're a great supplement to your alfresco pub sessions, with plenty of modern takes on classic pizzas, served in their chic, indoor-outdoor setting. Their wood-fired pizzas range from the rich and indulgent ‘Mushroom & Truffle’ with wild mushrooms, fior di latte, and a drizzle of truffle oil, to the fresh ‘Zucchini & Ricotta,’ topped with thinly sliced zucchini, lemon, and creamy ricotta.
14. Pizza Madre (Marrickville)
View this post on Instagram
For inner west vegetarians, Pizza Madre in Marrickville is the spot to know for its creative, seasonal toppings and sourdough bases. Their menu highlights include the ‘Pumpkin’ pizza, featuring roasted pumpkin, smoked ricotta, and sage, as well as the ‘Zucchini,’ topped with zucchini flowers, fresh mozzarella, and lemon. With a cozy, intimate setting and a focus on sustainable, locally sourced ingredients, Pizza Madre is a favourite for those seeking unique, flavourful vegetarian slices.
15. DOC Pizza (Surry Hills)
View this post on Instagram
DOC has outposts in both Melbourne and Sydney, and are the reigning supreme pizza joint when it comes to DOP cheeses. Their Sydney spot, close to Central Station, is small but vibrant – and offers their full suite of pizza options, as well as delicious pasta, lasagne and salad options.
16. The Corner House (Bondi)
View this post on Instagram
Bondi residents shouldn't overlook The Corner House in Bondi's laid-back wood-fired pizzas that take centre stage on their menu. Their ‘Spicy Sopressa’ pizza is a crowd-pleaser, featuring spicy salami, mozzarella, and chilli, while the ‘Pumpkin & Gorgonzola’ delivers a unique mix of roasted pumpkin, creamy gorgonzola, and walnuts. Just minutes from Bondi Beach, The Corner House combines rustic charm with beachside vibes, making it a favourite spot for locals to enjoy a slice and a glass of wine after a day in the sun.
